The Gate

Gargoyles #10 by David Hedgecock & Robby Bevard

"The Gate" is the tenth issue of the Gargoyles comic by SLG, and Chapter Ten of the Clan-Building story arc.

On August 31, 2008, SLG's license to produce single issues of the Gargoyles comic ended. The material that would have made up single issues nine through twelve is included in the trade paperback collection Gargoyles: Clan-Building, Volume Two.

• Writer/Creator: Greg Weisman
• Pencil Artist: Greg Guler
• Color Artist: Robby Bevard
• Art Director: Greg Guler
• Cover Pencil Artist: David Hedgecock
• Cover Color Artist: Robby Bevard

Solicitation

"The Gate." Brooklyn could really use some time away from the Clan, but when the time-traveling Phoenix Gate materializes before his eyes, maybe the phrase "look, but don't touch" should have come to mind. Careful what you wish for, Brooklyn!

Summary

Main Plot

While out on patrol, Brooklyn stumbles upon the Phoenix Gate with Angela and Broadway nearby. The gate dissolves into the Phoenix and swallows Brooklyn whole, sending him to Scotland in 997 A.D., near King Constantine and his men, who promptly attack the gargoyle. Brooklyn manages to escape, running into Mary and Finella (posing as pilgrims), also on the run from Constantine’s forces. Kenneth and his allies, Maol Chalvim and Findlaech, consider how to increase their ranks and, that night, Angel discovers a cell of her clan massacred along with a royal post from the party responsible.

Subplots

In 1997, Hudson and Lexington are not yet back from their adventure in England.

In the time since Constantine usurped the throne, he and his men have been destroying gargoyles to prevent his enemies from seeking them as allies, remembering the fate of his own father. They have also been posting pronouncements blaming Finella for the death of Kenneth II and Princess Katharine’s disappearance.

Brooklyn takes a sword from a guard that refused to provide refuge to Mary and Finella.

Among Constantine’s allies are Maíl Brigti and his son Gillecomgain.

Review

This chapter begins Brooklyn's TimeDancing, an event I had anticipated from early on. For one thing, the consequences of his adventures, buffeted about the time-stream, would result in building up the clan (as we shall see when we reach the end of "Phoenix"). For another, we knew from Greg Weisman that Broadway and Angela would be with Brooklyn when he came upon the Phoenix Gate, and once these three young gargoyles were left behind in New York in "The Rock", I felt certain that Greg was laying pipe for this scene. And I was right.

What I had not expected was *how* the Gate transported Brooklyn into the past. As Brooklyn reaches down to take it, the Gate disintegrates, and from it rises a monstrous bird made of fire – the Phoenix after which the Gate was named. Brooklyn is borne away by it, in a truly dramatic scene, carried off to Scotland in the year 997.

Through this unexpected time travel jaunt, we are reunited with old friends and enemies. Constantine, still the usurping King of Scotland, has made the young Gillecomgain (already filled with hatred for gargoyles after his encounter with Demona three years before) his squire; he also has the aid of the sinister sorcerer, Brother Valmont, a new character. Brooklyn, narrowly escaping them when the Phoenix deposits him in front of these three (plus Mail Brigti, Gillecomgain's father, whom we glimpsed earlier in "Hunter's Moon" Part One), finds himself in happier company: Mary and Finella, still on the run with the Grimorum Arcanorum, and hunted by Constantine. Brooklyn rescues them from some suspicious townsfolk, and they set off together.

Meanwhile, other human enemies of Constantine are gathering, under the leadership of the future Kenneth III (Bodhe's father), his cousin Maol Chalvim (whom we met in "Avalon" Part One), and Findlaech, Macbeth's father-to-be. Aware that they are outnumbered, Kenneth comments that their best hope is to revive the old alliance that their fathers made with gargoyles – but that's no easy task, with Constantine and Gillecomgain slaughtering all the gargoyles that they can find. As for Brooklyn, he realizes to his alarm that the only way of getting back to his own time will be to recover the broken pieces of the Phoenix Gate, and one of those pieces lies with his old enemy Demona....

Gargoyles' visits to medieval Scotland were among my favorite moments in the television series, and this does not disappoint; the story captures the tone of this bygone era effectively, weaving more of Scotland's early history into the story, just as "City of Stone" and "Avalon" Part One had done. I enjoyed this opening chapter, as well as the surprise team-ups of many of the familiar figures from the series' backstory, and looked forward to the next two chapters after that – which, fortunately, were not far behind....

First Appearances

Characters

• Phoenix
• Culen (Mentioned Only)
• Duff (Mentioned Only)
• Porter
• Magus (the horse)
• Brother Valmont
• Kenneth III

Magic

• Arrow Spell

Location

• Flatiron Building

Object

• Brooklyn's Sword

Miscellaneous

• Star Trek (Mentioned Only)

Tidbits

Brooklyn finds the Phoenix Gate on the roof of The Daily Bugle. The Daily Bugle is a metropolitan newspaper owned by J. Jonah Jameson, which usually smears Spider-Man while, ironically, buying photos of him from Peter Parker. Given all the Gargoyles references in The Spectacular Spider-Man, it is nice to see Spidey referenced in Gargoyles.

Constantine's lie about Finella having a son who was murdered by Kenneth II is based on Holinshed's account of Kenneth's downfall, where Finella helps murder Kenneth to avenge her son's death.

Finella uses the name "Fiona" as an alias. Both Finella in "Avalon" Part One and Fiona Canmore in "The Last" were voiced by Sheena Easton.

The cry of the frightened townspeople, "Run away! Run away!" is a homage to Monty Python and the Holy Grail.

Kenneth III's line "Welcome every man according to his station, and who shall 'scape whipping?" is an echo of Hamlet's line to Polonius in Act II Scene ii of Hamlet, "use every man after his desert, and who shall 'scape whipping?"

Star Trek, so often in the background of Gargoyles, is explicitly mentioned at last, when Brooklyn mentions it as one of two television science fiction programs he's seen (Quantum Leap being the other).

In this issue, and the next two ("Tyrants" and "Phoenix"), the pages' background (surrounding the panels) is white during the daytime scenes and black during the scenes set at night and changes mid-page during the dawn and dusk scenes.

The research about 10th Century Scotland that went into Brooklyn's first TimeDancer story in this issue (and both "Tyrants" and "Phoenix") is credited to Kathy Pogge. [1]

<< Previous Episode: "Clan-Building" Chapter Nine: "Rock of Ages"

Next Episode: "Clan-Building" Chapter Eleven: "Tyrants" >>