From GargWiki
Revision as of 17:43, 10 August 2023 by Antiyonder (talk | contribs)
Jump to: navigation, search
Bad Guys #3: by Greg Guler & Robby Bevard

"Estranged" is the third issue of the Gargoyles: Bad Guys comic by SLG, and Chapter Three of the Redemption story arc. It was released on May 21, 2008. The issue was reprinted in Gargoyles: Bad Guys - Redemption.


While Hunter, Dingo, Matrix and Yama are in Manhattan, trying to uncover why Doctor Sevarius freed Fang from prison, Hunter takes a break from the team to make peace with her wayward brothers – Jason Canmore and John Castaway!


Main Plot

Dingo armors up with Matrix while Hunter jumps on a robot, destroying it with a grenade before getting caught by another.

Two weeks earlier, Dingo, Matrix, and Yama continue to train at the Redemption Squad's headquarters below the Eiffel Tower. Hunter visits Notre Dame Cathedral and thinks back to the night her father was killed by Demona and how she and her brothers pursued “the Demon” into the Parisian catacombs. In New York, Hunter briefs the Squad about their target, Anton Sevarius, and their mission to figure out why he keeps visiting the New York's underground tunnels. Dingo grows bored and he and Matrix pursue Sevarius before sunset. Hunter and Yama go underground and find themselves face to face with Fang.


Dingo reminds Hunter that she's also wanted in New York for blowing up the 23rd Precinct.

While in New York, Hunter visits her brothers Jason and Jon, the first in rehab at Rikers Island and the second now the head of the Quarrymen under the guise of John Castaway.

The Story


Review by Todd W. Jensen.

Like the first two issues of Bad Guys, "Estranged" opens with more of the Redemption Squad's battle with the flying robots, focusing now on the actions of Dingo, Matrix (who once again becomes Dingo's flying suit of armor), and Hunter. Just as Hunter has been caught by one of the robots, however, we return to the flashback story.

Indeed, we have a flashback within a flashback, as Hunter remembers the night of her father's death (familiar to Gargoyles fans from the opening scene in "Hunter's Moon" Part Three), and how she and her brothers pursued Demona into the Parisian catacombs immediately afterwards. Demona speaks for the first time in any of the Gargoyles comic books (main or spin-off), and assumes one of her most nightmarish performances yet – especially when she reaches out from behind a wall of skulls to seize the young Robyn.

This additional flashback is all the more effective, as it runs alongside Hunter's meeting with her two brothers in New York. During her conversation with Jason Canmore (now working hard to rebuild himself), she helps him back to his wheelchair after he falls; in the flashback, we see Jason similarly helping her out of the pile of skulls after Demona flees. And when Hunter meets with John Castaway, we see a flashback to the young Jon Canmore begging his sister to forget about the gargoyle feud; in the present, their roles have reversed as Hunter attempts to persuade Castaway to renounce his war on the gargoyles, and fails. In one of the most moving scenes in the comic, as Hunter leaves the Quarryman Brownstone, we see the door to the building closing on a picture of the young Jon and Robyn.

The other members of the Redemption Squad are in the background, but continue to enjoy their own moments. Dingo gets to turn the tables on Hunter when he reveals that he's learned about her blowing up the Clock Tower (or might have turned the tables if she had not simply said "Your point being?"). We see each of them in their rooms at the Casablanca Hotel (their local headquarters in New York): Dingo is watching a Celebrity Hockey game on television while going through a series of drinks, Yama stands at attention in his stone sleep (with his weapons and gear lying on his bed), and Matrix has reverted to puddle-form on his own bed. And near the end, Dingo gets tired of waiting for their mission (to go after Sevarius) to begin and heads off with Matrix; Yama reports to Hunter, in a delightfully deadpan manner, "He was... 'bored'."

We only get a brief glimpse of Castaway (I was hoping for more, especially after seeing him in "Invitation Only"), but he's still handled well. His commercial for the Quarrymen is another highlight of the issue: he takes care to sound in it like a gentle, reasonable man, reaching out to frightened New Yorkers and offering to help them. And he is as aware that his sister's working for someone else as she is that he didn't set up the Quarrymen on his own.

Sevarius is revealed as the Redemption Squad's target (though the ending of "The Lost" hinted at that); he's up to something, though neither we nor the Redemption Squad know what it is. (We also learn, on the side, that he was apparently responsible for the thylacines in "Strangers"; it would be like him to engage in Jurassic Park-style activity.) The hunt for him leads Hunter into a sewer to find herself face to face with what is apparently Fang – while she recalls, once more, her childhood encounter with Demona....

First Appearances



Alicea from Blue Mug Productions.

Alicea, from Blue Mug Productions makes a cameo appearance painting Notre Dame Cathedral. [1]

The first five pages are adapted from the Bad Guys Leica reel, like the opening pages in the first two issues.

Jason, Robyn, and Jon's encounter with Demona in the Parisian catacombs is based on a draft of "Hunter's Moon" Part Three (staged as a radio play at the 2001 Gathering) in which Charles Canmore pursued Demona from Notre Dame Cathedral to the catacombs, followed by his children, and was killed there; the events in the catacombs flashback are revised to fit the televised episode.

After the flashback to the clock tower's destruction, we see the Redemption Squad's helicopter flying past the 23rd Precinct's Clock Tower, now being rebuilt.

The Celebrity Hockey broadcast in the Rikers Island gymnasium contains one of the longest in-jokes in Gargoyles yet; all of the hockey players are named after Gargoyles voice actors: Easton (after Sheena Easton, the voice of Robyn Canmore), Bader (after Diedrich Bader, the voice of Jason Canmore), Bennett (after Jeff Bennett, who voiced Matrix in the Bad Guys Leica reel), Belushi (after Jim Belushi, the voice of Fang), Devane (after William Devane, who voiced the Director, Hunter's boss, in the Bad Guys Leica reel), Tagawa (after Cary-Hiroyuki Tagawa, who voiced Yama in the Bad Guys Leica reel), Cummings (after Jim Cummings, the voice of Dingo), Cumming (after Alan Cumming, the voice of John Castaway in "The Journey"), and Cleverdon (after Scott Cleverdon, the voice of Jon Canmore, and then in The Goliath Chronicles as Castaway in all appearances after "The Journey"). Two specific lines add extra in-jokes: "Puck's recovered by Spiner... Bennett checks him" (Puck was voiced by Brent Spiner, and Owen by Jeff Bennett), and "Cumming is blindsided by Cleverdon" (Cleverdon succeeded Cumming as the voice of Jon Canmore/Castaway for the rest of The Goliath Chronicles after Cumming had replaced him for "The Journey").

Dingo refers to Wolf's mutation in "Upgrade"; we now learn that Sevarius handled it.

The pad of paper on the cover appears to be "Weisman" brand (though the "W" is covered up).


<< Previous Episode: "Redemption, Chapter Two: The Lost" Next Episode: "Redemption" Chapter Four: "Louse" >>